Today, I decided to completely do away with Google Apps for my primary domains. The reasons are numerous but, for sake of brevity, I’ll list my top 5 reasons with a bit of detail for each.
I’ve been meaning to look at alternatives to Google Apps for some time now. I don’t really use many of Google’s apps except mail, calendar, and contacts. Most of what I do use is tied to my Gmail address so it really doesn’t do me much good to keep my domains on Google Apps anymore. That could be reason enough but, honestly, there are a number of things that made me want to do away with Google Apps and seek out alternatives:
1. IMAP is wonky and ssslllooowww!
Google’s IMAP implementation isn’t exactly to spec so many email clients and apps have problems with it. Heck, Apple has been fighting with it for the past two years trying to get performance issues squared away with the default Mail application in Mac OS X. On top of that, it’s slow as molasses and sometimes takes forever to bring up new mail. Performance and reliability are the two things that I expect the most out of the online services I use…especially email. Which is why I’m having a hard time understanding why Google, one of the biggest internet providers, isn’t as fast and reliable as it should be.
2. Spam protection not as good as Gmail
Since switching to Google Apps, I’ve noticed that spam protection is a bit hit and miss compared to Gmail. With Gmail, I rarely had any legitimate email land in the Spam folder. With Google Apps though, it always seems like the same email ends up in the Spam folder no matter what I did. I tried updating the spam settings in Google Apps several times, adding email addresses to a “legit" list, but they kept landing in Spam anyways. Kinda frustrating to say the least. Why is there such a discrepancy between how spam protection works between Gmail and Google Apps?
3. Quirky calendar behavior
I typically use a combination of the default Apple Calendar apps (OS X and iOS) and Fantastical for all my calendaring needs. For the most part, integration with Google calendars works but with some quirks. On occasion, I’ve had problems moving an event from one calendar to another, which results either in an error or the event getting stuck on a specific calendar. I’ve also had problems with invites where the same invite keeps showing up in the Calendar inbox and can’t be dismissed. Both issues were rather annoying and, when they happen, about the only solution is to delete the event and recreate it.
4. Privacy concerns
This is a rather mild complaint but one that I’m still a bit concerned about. Many folks online have raised concerns about how Google uses information about activity and data use with Google apps. Their passive approach to parsing keywords and text in email for better ad placement is one thing. But what about the data they collect on our activity within all the different Google-based applications? Are they selling this data? Personally, I’m less concerned about anyone knowing what I do online than I am not know whether a company is selling this information without my knowledge. Transparency seems to be the big issue here and, while it’s a minor gripe, it’s still one that has a bit of weight in my decision to not use Google Apps.
Something tells me that Google will likely do away with IMAP (and POP) altogether in favor of dedicated apps using Google API’s. Same applies to Apple’s calendar apps which might not be playing nice with the Google API’s. Again, this may not necessarily be Apple’s fault. My guess is that Apple may be trying to maintain a standardized approach using CalDAV with the Calendar apps but, just like IMAP, Google’s implementation is rather quirky causing some issues with certain features. Granted, IMAP, POP, and even CalDAV are pretty old standards so it would be understandable if Google did away with them in favor of a more modernized approach. However, doing so will greatly narrow the software solutions businesses have in using Google Apps. As such, I would imagine many businesses will migrate away from Google Apps if this happens to avoid any sort of lock-in.
So, what did I end up doing?
Well, for starters, I switched to FastMail for email. So far, I’m impressed with the speed and responsiveness of their servers. I can definitely tell a difference between using FastMail and using Google Apps. It’ll be a while before I know how well spam protection works but my first impression is good.
For calendar and contacts, because I’m in an all Apple environment, I decided to stick with iCloud. Syncing is pretty stable and almost instant. Invites are also more stable and just work as expected. Right now, I don’t have need of any business solutions but in the future, if I do, I’ll likely just use FastMail to share calendars and contacts between multiple users.
For file syncing, I’m currently sticking with Dropbox. I tried Google Drive but just found that it doesn’t work well for syncing data with apps like 1Password and TextExpander. I considered switching to iCloud Drive but found that there still isn’t any apps that allow for browsing your files like you can with Dropbox. Plus, unlike Dropbox, iCloud Drive doesn’t appear to allow you to share files and folders with others in a collaborative way, which is critical for most of the projects I work on. What I’ll likely end up doing is keeping Dropbox for basic business use and using iCloud for personal stuff.
For documents (notes, spreadsheets, presentations), I rarely used Google except for the occasional spreadsheet. Most of the documents I create tend to be within Apple-based apps like Page and Keynote. For notes and text-based document, I mostly use Evernote. I’m also considering the use of Markdown documents for the creation of web content in an effort to speed up the process of converting semantic text to HTML. Most of these documents end up in a folder that gets synced up through Dropbox for easy sharing and backups.
I’ll still maintain my Gmail account, which I’ve had forever, but will keep a fairly low profile with it. It’ll primarily be used for Google+, YouTube, and that sort of thing. One thing I should look into is updating my Google profile and see if I can turn off certain settings in an effort to maintain greater anonymity. I’m sure there are features that can be turned off but, like Facebook, they’re probably buried under 9 million different sub levels of settings.
Suffice to say, I’m glad I switched away from Google Apps. The upside is that I can pick and choose which solutions are the best for me while maintaining a level of privacy that I’m comfortable with. Along with that comes a nice boost in performance which, when it comes to productivity, is always a good thing. Like they always say, “time is money”, right?